Quote:
You are absolutely right. JW's leave the sect but
retain the mental attitudes of the Watchtower followers
and the WTBS
Namely:
I prolly should ignore this post, dear VG (peace to you!), but you raise some legitimate issues that perhaps others are curious about. To leave it as you're IMPLYING (as to here, though I don't know why, if what you say is CORRECT, you feel you need to be all... ummmmm... covert and indirect about it. Could be that rafter, but, well... only you know that), though, isn't fair to others who might read it and have such curiosity. So, let's review it, from the perspective of THIS forum and those who post HERE, shall we? Because I think you are making assumptions based on not TRULY understanding where you are and among whom (yeah, I know - sounds "superior", doesn't it? Only if you take it that way, though...):
Quote:
(1) Thinking whatever they now believe is the only religion acceptable to God
If you are directing that to THIS forum and those who post HERE, you are mistaken: most of us don't believe in religion of ANY kind... or that religion of ANY kind is acceptable to God. Most of us know that the ONLY religion ever SANCTIONED by God was the one HE formed: the institution He set up through Moses, that started with a tabernacle in the wilderness of Sinai and culminated with a temple in Jerusalem... which temple was destroyed... twice... both times with God's permission... and the second time after He utterly REJECTED it... as well as the FORM OF RELIGION practiced IN it... when He removed His SPIRIT from it... and put that spirit in His SON... who then put(s) that spirit in OTHERS... making THEM the "temple" of God. As a result, there is NO "religion" on EARTH that worships God... because not only does He not dwell in handmade temples, but in His PEOPLE... but those who DO worship Him must DO so:
1. In SPIRIT;
2. In TRUTH;
3. THROUGH Christ.
And by "through" Christ, I don't mean "in the name of 'Jesus'" but by literally going THROUGH Christ so as to even come BEFORE God. Those who simply utter prayers "in the name of 'Jesus'" overlook two (2) very important TRUTHS:
1. There is no "Jesus" (that is NOT the name of the Son of God), so praying in THAT name is not what gets one IN... or one's prayers HEARD; and
2. Just because one utters the name of "Jesus" does NOT mean one has actually gotten IN, indeed, one has NOT if they have not gone TO him and ASKED to be given ACCESS... and so such one is like the Pharisee... who merely prayed "to himself."
Now, everything I just shared with you I received from my dear Lord, the HOLY One of Israel and Holy Spirit, JAHESHUA, the Chosen One of JAH (MischaJah)... BUT... it is included in the Bible. Every bit of it. So, if you doubt ME... or even doubt HIM (because HE could tell you, if you only had faith so as to HEAR him)... you can READ about it, for yourself. Please let me know if you need to know the specific scriptures and verses; otherwise, I am going to assume you already know them.
Now, do we... some of us... believe what we know and understand is the only TRUTH? Some of us do. I do. But that isn't because I received it from some man (or woman)... or thought of it myself. It is because I received it FROM the [One Who is] the Truth.
Quote:
(2) Other paths, other churches and other denominations are not "in the truth"
I can only speak for myself but MY basis for understanding this isn't because of what I "think." It's because of what I've been TOLD... by the One... the ONLY One... who SAYS who is "in" him. Since HE's the TRUTH... then I have to take HIS word for it. I mean, he should KNOW... yes? And so if HE says to me that HE doesn't know (as in "yada"... and in intimately... as in he in they and they in him) ones... then who am I to dispute that with HIM?
Quote:
(3) Thinking only themselves and their group have the "right way" the "real thing"
I hate to be the one to tell you, but I think that, by your comment, YOU are doing the very thing you are accusing others of. Because you DO believe YOU are right... and have the "real thing" yes... and "we" are wrong/do not? On what, though, do you base your position? Your OWN thinking? The thinking given you by other humans? Or what you've heard from Christ himself? Since the only truly RELIABLE source would be Christ himself... you, too, must hear him, then... yes? And if so, how do you take issue with any HERE who make that claim?
And please don't think that after making such a statement, refusing to answer my questions to YOU will suffice to show you as "right." It won't. It will only show that you DON'T KNOW of what you're speaking and accusing others of... but which to APPEAR "knowledgeable." Unless you can ANSWER as to what is propounded to YOU, however... I have no choice but to assume YOU the ignorant one.
Quote:
(4) The need to "correct" others thinking and align them with their own ideas.
This comment TOTALLY confuses me. I mean, you claim to be a "christian," yes? Yet, did not CHRIST correct others thinking... so as to align them with his??? And did he not tell his DISCIPLES:
"Go... and make disciples of people of ALL nations... teaching them to OBEY/OBSERVE... ALL the things I've commanded YOU"?? How does one fulfill that COMMAND, if one doesn't do what HE did... and told THEM to do??? And how does one claim to be a CHRISTIAN... if one DOESN'T do what Christ SAID to do?? Oh, wait... that's right: you're of that "all they need do is believe in him and call him 'Lord' thinking." SAY they belong to/know him. I don't think HE sees it that way, though. At least, he SAID he didn't.
Quote:
(5) The idea God is dealing with them exclusively and "speaking to them".
God? I don't think
anyone here thinks
that. I certainly don't. Most HERE knows that He only deals "
exclusively" with Christ, His Son. Christ, on the other hand, deals both exclusively AND as a group with those who the Father has GIVEN him, yes. Surely, you know THAT... yes? I can give you a PLETHORA of examples. Individually, first, then perhaps as part of a group. But individually even so. For example, Philip. Saul of Tarsus. Peter. John. Lazarus. Stephen. The Samaritan woman. Mary the Magdalene. ALL were dealt with exclusively by my dear Lord. AND as part of a group. Sometimes not even the SAME group (Saul of Tarsus aka Paul was not one of the "12" nor was he always dealt with as part of that group and those who went with them - but you know that, yes?).
As for speaking to them, God has ALWAYS spoken to His people. Heck, He even spoke to Cain. And just as he said he did whatever the Father did... and taught HIM... Christ speaks to HIS people. Surely, you've read in your Bible where he tells us THAT... yes? And where Lazarus reiterates it?
Quote:
(6) Intolerance towards Catholics, Jews, Lutherans, Anglicans, etc etc or any
non-fundamentalist group of Christians.
Again, I'm confused. You cannot mean us, here. Because NO ONE... HERE... is intolerant of these. Well, okay, we have one or two who have expressed some intolerance. But one does not claim to be of Christ's Body at all and while the other professes to be a christian, we have spoken with him on his intolerance and he understands he needs to keep his opinions on such levels to himself and off THIS board. Otherwise, no one here is intolerant of ANYONE. Not even practicing JWs. Or practicing Catholics. Indeed, until recently, one of our dear moderators was a Catholic. Had been since this place started (and elsewhere before). Another of our moderators is agnostic. We even "tolerate" atheists... something YOU seem to have a problem with. I'm not sure what you THINK you "know" about "us"... but if you are referring to US... you are very much in error.
Quote:
Viewing these as not legitimate, lesser than
and not acceptable to God.
As to such religions being illegitimate, yes. You are correct; we... some of us... and certainly me... know them to be illegitimate. But that doesn't make them lesser than or unacceptable to God - only makes them not part of the Body of Christ. But although Abraham loved Isaac and made him heir... because of the status of his MOTHER, Abraham's FREE wife, Sarah... Abraham STILL loved Ishmael... his illegitimate son by the slave girl, Hagar. And while Ishmael didn't share in the inheritance reserved for Isaac, Abraham STILL provided... and very well... for him.
In the same way, while we... I... understand that there are "sheep" who are of Christ's BODY... and so not only attain everlasting life by means of him, but RULE with him in his kingdom... "Isaac"... there are also "sheep" who also receive that life by doing GOOD to his brothers. "Ishmael." BOTH are well-care for, luv.
But it is NOT us who constitute some as "goats." Such ones do that themselves. By their own mouths... and lack of love and faith... they judge themselves.
Quote:
(7) Thinking they have "special knowledge" SPECIAL KNOWLEDGE is the prime identifier
of the Cult Mentality
Well, then, you CERTAINLY cannot mean anyone HERE. Because NO ONE... HERE... believes they are special... or have special knowledge. If THAT were the case we (1) would not SHARE it but keep it TO ourselves, perhaps only allowing an "exclusive" few access to it... yet, here YOU are... and you didn't have to jump through any hoops to get here; and (2) not profess ourselves to be SERVANTS of others, and put ourselves IN service to other... but require that others serve US. Yet, you will not find ANY such request HERE.
Quote:
the idea you "know things" and understand God's will while others
do not.
It's not an idea, luv. It's the truth. EVERYONE in union with Christ will... should... "know things", including God's will. Yes? Else, how can one DO God's will? Now, if logic serves, you, TOO, must think you "know things" that others do not... just by your commentary HERE. AND... by your (repeatedly stated) education. AND by the fact that you've chosen one (particular) religion (christianity) over another (say, Islam). Surely, you believe YOU know things that those in Islam DON'T... yes? And YOU understand "God's will" while those folks "do not." Yes? Your position as to what's occurring in GAZA says THAT, dear one. Else, you would CONDESCEND to consider that PERHAPS... YOU... are WRONG... on that matter. But... you do not (condescend) to consider it. Which means you believe THEY are wrong... that YOU know and "understand God's will" as to THIS matter... and THEY "do not."
Well, I have to tell you, dear, dear VG... you are wrong. About a lot of things. Especially your assumptions regarding this site, the people here, and our faith. Had you taken a moment and maybe just chilled and OBSERVED... you might not have led yourself to look as foolish as you do, right now. You came here, though, upset and angry over what had occurred with you on ANOTHER site. Rather than move on from there in PEACE... you came HERE... and attacked US. Came here and tried to do to US the same as was done to YOU... THERE.
We, however, received you (again, I immediately called out one who I thought was VERY rude to you and requested an apology! Rather than acknowledge that, you turned on ME! NOT because of my SPIRITUAL position, but my POLITICAL position. Which you, obviously, cannot separate. I, though, was like, "What the...???" It would be like me taking issue with anyone who spoke against Baptists cause my PEOPLE are Baptists. Yet, YOU posted very accurately as to how BAPTISTS conducted themselves during U.S. slavery - to this day, I can't fathom why anyone Black would want to BE a Baptist... or a Democrat... well, or a Republican... but that's just ME. I digress.).
Now, you want to take what we are sharing among ourselves as a personal attack on YOU... when, for the most part, no one has really addressed your "religion." I'm not even sure what it IS... other than you stating it as "christian." You take issue because I have a different opinion than you are to the various "denominations"... yet, YOU apparently have a problem with at least one NON-christian religion. To ME... and I don't think I'm alone... religion... is religion. Whether it calls itself "christian," or "Islam" or "Hindu" or "Buddhism" or "Anglican" or "Catholic" or "Roman Catholic" or "Baptist" or "Southern Baptist"... or "Bible Students"... or "Jehovah's Witnesses"... or "JWs." It is ALL... RELIGION.
And, for the most part, we here... don't do... religion. We do... Christ. Who condemned the only religion established by God... and NEVER REPLACED IT (with religion). He replaced it, if you KNEW him (and you can read about him so as to at least know this one FACT)... with ANTI-religion.
Because it is religion, dear one, that MOST exhibits itself as anti-CHRIST.
Quote:
That is the ultimate mark of a Jehovah's Witness mentality.
Actually, it is you who is still exhibiting that "mark." You did so when came here, into OUR "house"... ridiculed OUR "way" and proferred YOURS... then insulted US for not accepting it. As we ALL know JWs do! You, dear one, learned well. That you think you've "left" them and are doing something DIFFERENT... in only a lie you are telling yourself. And, right now, only you believe it.
Put ASIDE your anger, though, your need to judge, and YOUR intolerance... step BACK... take a moment to SEE... and perhaps not only will you SEE that that has been YOUR "mentality" here, but also what we are TRULY about... versus what you THINK we are.
Alternatively, you can consider that perhaps this is NOT the site YOU need (it to be) and will consider returning to the one you were on previously (although, you may have to apologize and show some contrition, which I don't perceive is something easy for you to do)... or moving on to another.
If you choose to stay HERE, though, I have to tell you: you continually raise up the fact that you are "educated," while putting others here down. Please know... you are not the only one HERE with a degree. Not even. However, since you have such store IN your education, I have asked that YOU be held to a HIGHER standard of conduct... one YOUR "education" should have trained you for... than perhaps the rest of us "uneducated dummies". So, please take heed. If you want us to treat YOU like YOUR "special"... because you have an education... then expect to be treated LIKE someone "special"... educated.
In that light, check your puerile, whiney melarkey at the door... and enter with your "educated" intelligence... or risk being escorted right back out. Which I believe you're not a stranger to.
Peace to you. Truly. If you can receive it. If not... then it will come back to rest on me, and I readily receive it.
YOUR servant, as I am servant to ALL those of the Household of God, Israel, and those who go with, and a slave of Christ,
Shellamar, who isn't any more intimidated by "educated" people... than I was by the uneducated folks of the WTBTS...